The Fog of
War
Being a Secretary of Defense in any state doesn’t only mean being someone who sometimes consider as principal assistant to the President in all matters and has an authority, direction and control over the Department of Defense. It is not just a duty, but a mere obligation for the welfare of state. Being appointed in that particular position is being the person in charge in the chain of command, both for operational and administrative purposes.
War can be defined as a state of armed
conflict between different nations or states or different groups within a
nation or state, in the film, fog of war is considered as complex and it’s
beyond the ability of the human mind to comprehend all the variables.
What does it feel to be the Secretary
of Defense under John F. Kennedy and Lyndon B. Johnson who were the two former
president of United States of America?
Well, Robert S. McNamara, who is best known for helping lead the
U.S. into the Vietnam War is the highlight of the film. The life of R.S.
McNamara is not a typical life of a government servant, for him it is the
period of moral consequences on how to defend the state where he belongs.
Human Nature is a
behavioral traits of humankind and it is regarded as shared by all humans. “Not
being rational”, as McNamara said.
Nobody’s perfect, in this world full of
circumstances, we all make decisions that are not acceptable by the people
around us. We all make mistakes, and even the highest and most respected
official makes it.
All things are possible, anything can
happen within a day, an hour, minute or even in a smack of second. Giving your
best toward difficulties is a good sign of perseverance which I learned in the
portion of never say never.
Norman Morrison who is known as a
Quaker, at first I had a glimpse of consciousness of why he is known for that
term, as I listen further I was like “oh God!” am I hearing it right or maybe
the sounds are cracked up. But then, what I heard was real.
Morrison doused himself in kerosene and
set himself on fire below Secretary of Defense
Robert McNamara's Pentagon office which leads to his death. Morrison’s wife
issued a statement or shall I say a moving statement that “Human beings must
stop killing other human beings”, which McNamara shared as his belief for many
times.
War is cruel. War is cruelty, and in order to do well, you have to
engage in evil. In liberalist’s point of view war and aggression are inevitable
but can be moderated.
International level of analysis is very close to this topic where
McNamara and LeMay focus on their strategy for the goals of their state.
Responsibilities are vested to any
officials like McNamara and LeMay who was then trying to save their nation and
prepared to do whatever killing was necessary. For others, it is inhuman and
difficult to understand. Omniscient or understanding is important in connection
with neighboring countries. Preparation is needed for it changes every time.
Belief and seeing are both often wrong,
sometimes we tend to believe on what we want see which is wrong which makes us
blind that covers the reality.
International Relations lies near in the heart of many matters
such as public concerns, as well as in the business world where competition is
high.
Profit is an essential thing for
marketers, it is the fruit of their labors. Getting the data are important for
economic matters, in a study made by the manager of Ford Company,
it can be concluded that people who can afford more but spend
their money on cheaper things are professionals such as doctors, professors and
lawyers etc., they are wise enough when it comes to consumption. Many people
won’t believe that Americans wanted cheaper cars.
Robert S. McNamara became the first
president of Ford Company who is not part of the Ford family, unfortunately
after five weeks he quit, not because he wasn’t capable of the field but
because he has something to do which is a great responsibility after all.
Someone introduced himself named Robert
Kennedy (brother-in-law of Jack Kennedy) who was authorized, offered to
McNamara the position of Secretary of Treasury, out of surprise he said that he
knows little about finance, after a while R. Kennedy asked him the position of
Secretary of Defense. It was a great opportunity for McNamara as being one of
the highest paid executives in the world. Many things will change. McNamara
insisted that he was not qualified for that position but Kennedy asked McNamara
to assume the responsibilities of Secretary of Defense right away.
The U.S. - Japanese War can be classified as the most brutal wars
in human history, many cases of suicide were recorded.
Curtis LeMay who was the finest combat
of any service for McNamara, but many thought that he was a brutal man. By
LeMay’s command, two nuclear bomb was dropped in different cities of Japan. Proportionality
should be a guideline in war, McNamara’s point is a critical concept that killing
people should be proportional on objectives to achieve their goal.
McNamara said that LeMay was the only person that he knew in the
senior command of Airforce who thinks on the loss of his crews per unit of
target. LeMay was focused on one thing, which is to target destruction.
On the other hand, McNamara admitted that they had a problem in
maximizing efficiency, he said that things must be done in a short period of
time to eliminate non-important scenarios especially in times of war where time
is something that could make anything.
A responsibility is something beyond
one’s self, McNamara took philosophy classes such as logic and ethics which he
is proud of. After graduating at University of California, he then went to
Harvard Graduate School where he earned his Master’s Degree in business.
In his comeback to San Francisco, it was the period where he starts
to build a family of his own.
Life of McNamara is something worth
studying, for he was a man of Excellency. McNamara has sharp analytical skills
in his work which he used on military situations. Another thing where McNamara
is famous of being innovative manager of Ford Company in promoting safety for
consumers or buyers.
For McNamara, it is important that the human race should be a
wide-thinker of conflict. People must engage in understanding the real meaning
of war and the killings behind it. Many officials of McNamara’s time was
Rational, which came that close to total destruction of their societies that
exists today, for McNamara, it was luck that save and prevented them from
nuclear war.
Generals Maxwell Taylor and Curtis LeMay were the persons who advocated bombing in
Cuba, for them they should strive hard when there was still time and advantage
of missiles.- a rationalist one.
“Rationality will not save
us”, making mistakes is a situation where we lost our control over something we
are not aware of effects.
When it comes to Individual level of
analysis, I shall connect it to the people in charge of decision making.
Decision makers are not just a group of people or individual who strive for
something that can benefit their country, they are individuals who thinks of
the nature and causes of their choice and perceptions.
“Emphatize
with your enemy”, which greatly affects the crisis. McNamara suggests that in
order for them to understand the opinions of their enemy, they should look
through the eyes. They were really close to that Cuban Missile Crisis that can
result to a major problem of state.
First thing that stayed in my mind was
the word empathy, what does it feel to be the oppressed? Or oppressor? It’s not
because you are on the peak of something today means you won’t ever get down.
We should be matured enough that life is but a dream, we are the controller of
our life but each of us has destiny that no one knows.
“Coercion,
after all, merely captures man. Freedom captivates him.”-Robert S.
McNamara